Hey Dr. Gupta, you don’t have to be a brain surgeon to know that our healthcare system needs an overhaul!

Yesterday, I watched with great delight as Michael Moore ripped Wolf Blitzer and his CNN colleague, Dr. Sanjay Gupta, a new you-know-what in response to the good doctor’s biased review of Moore’s latest film, Sicko.

Good for Michael Moore!

And shame on Dr. Gupta for trying to muddy the waters on a much-needed debate about the state of our country’s healthcare system. Michael Moore does a good job of rebutting Dr. Gupta’s review (with a few shots taken at CNN’s coverage of the lead-up to the Iraq war, to boot) so I’m not going to repeat any of it.

But I do feel the need to call the good doctor out on some other points.

According to a WHO report (see also my earlier post on how the US did against other industrialized nations), the US healthcare system ranks 37th in the world, behind all other industrialized nations. Rather than address this startling fact (made even more startling because the US is today the richest country in the world), Dr. Gupta chooses to elide by pointing out that Cuba (featured in Sicko) was ranked 39th!

Um . . . in case you hadn’t noticed, Doctor, Cuba is a small Caribbean island that has endured an economic embargo for the better part of the last half-century. You should be ashamed that this poor country was only two points behind the US in this WHO ranking. I mean, it’s not like when the Founding Fathers set out to build this country, their goal was to create a country with a better health care system than Cuba! And, last time I checked, the Cuban government was not proud enough of the way they do things to invade other countries and bring them a better way of life. We should be ashamed that, despite the wealth and power of the US, we only beat Cuba—which has neither the economic power nor physical infrastructure of the US—by two points!!!

Unlike Dr. Sanjay Gupta, I’m no brain surgeon so I can’t comment on how healthcare works here and abroad, but I do have some experience with the US and British healthcare systems. In the US, my health insurance contribution comes directly out of my paycheck because, unlike millions of other Americans, I’m lucky enough to have a job that provides me with subsidized health insurance. Then, every time I go to the doctor, I pay a $30 co-pay (because I was stupid enough to choose the HMO option). If I have to see a specialist after a visit to my primary-care doctor, I have to pay the specialist a $40 co-pay. Then, if I go the pharmacy to fill a prescription, I have to pay again for my medication. Finally, if I have any bloodwork or other tests done by a lab, I get a bill from the lab. At the end of the scenario outlined above (which happens with some regularity), I end up paying five times! And I’m one of the lucky ones who has health insurance through my work. We all know someone who’s been brought to the brink of financial ruin for failing to get pre-approval for an ambulance ride or an overnight stay in the hospital (as if these kinds of emergencies can ever be planned in advance!).

Compare this to the British healthcare system (NHS). I spent a year doing my Masters degree in London and went to the doctor a couple of times. The doctor’s visit was free and I was able to see him at my own convenience, within a few days of calling to make the appointment. My blood tests were free. My annual HIV test was free. I just walked into the clinic, wrote down my name on a clipboard and waited to be called. When I went to the pharmacy to fill out my prescription, the guy behind the counter took the Rx note and came right back with a bottle of pills and some other stuff. I started walking back to the door and realized I hadn’t paid him. I went back and asked him how much I owed. He asked me, “You’re diabetic, right?” I said I was. He then told me diabetes medication is free under NHS!!!

Granted I was studying in Britain and I had paid my tuition already (which by the way was much cheaper than tuition here) but that’s not why I was eligible for free NHS care. As a visitor on longer than a six-month visa, I was entitled to the same health benefits as British nationals! How many foreign students in the US get such a good deal?

So back to Dr. Sanjay Gupta, who proudly declared in his review of Sicko that waiting periods in European countries for procedures like hip replacements are longer than in the US. Fair enough. But how often does the average person go to the hospital for a hip replacement? And what about the millions of Americans who work part-time (often part-time at multiple jobs so they end up working more than 40-hour weeks) but don’t have health insurance through any one employer? They may not have to wait as long as their German counterparts to have their hips replaced but without health insurance, how do they pay for their hip replacements? Or for that matter, basic healthcare needs?

Sure, Cuba may have a worse healthcare system than we do (but not by much, apparently) but that’s not something to gloat about. Despite that country’s small size and economic stagnation, their healthcare system is only slightly worse than ours. Nonetheless, according to the CIA World Factbook, Cuba has a lower infant mortality rate than Chile and Argentina, two of the most developed countries in Latin America, and a slightly lower infant mortality rate than the US. Before anyone dismisses these figures as Cuban government propaganda, let me remind you these figures come from the CIA. Why would the CIA lie in Cuba’s favor?

So Dr. Gupta—in a clear case of shooting the messenger—tries to undermine Michael Moore’s credibility rather than talk about the problems of our healthcare system. But the truth is, it doesn’t take a brain surgeon to know our system is messed up. Maybe Sanjay Gupta should take a break from playing doctor and devote some more time to being a journalist. It’s high time he and other people in the mainstream media started asking tough questions about the pressing issues of the day.


2 thoughts on “Hey Dr. Gupta, you don’t have to be a brain surgeon to know that our healthcare system needs an overhaul!

  1. Rabia,

    Thanks for reading my blog and leaving a comment.

    I do agree with that Frenchman that we are scared of our government. In France, they’re quick to strike, demonstrate, burn some hay bales on the highway, and generally engage in dirsuptive behavior.

    The other point from that movie that struck me was the fact that most American college grads will have accumulated thousands of dollars of debt before they even get their first professional job. An indebted employee is a pliant and quiescent employee, and nothing makes an employer (or a government) happier than a pliance and quiescence.

    Our system is rotten to the core.

    Glad to hear you’re fighting the good fight. 🙂


  2. Thanks for writing about this. I think one of the best points from SICKO was when they asked a Frenchman why France was able to adopt policies that benefit he people like: universal health care, 32 hr work week, 6 weeks paid vacation, etc…, but the American government has failed to adopt any similar policies. His answer was something like, In France the government is scared of the people (of protests, etc), but in America the people are scared of the government.
    I’m tired of being scared. I feel like WE THE PEOPLE need to get mad and stop feeling afraid that we will seem un-American if we critique or criticize the work of the people we elected into office when they don’t stand up for the good of the whole. Also pray to the good God above that He feels it is time for an awakening in American and time for change… and time for Obama to be our next president. Just my opinion… 🙂 Keep talking on this point!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s